Twitter: Helpful or Harmful?

Being a fanatic about something is no new phenomenon. From the very first Olympic games, people have gathered to watch and cheer for their favorite contestant competing in an event. With the inventions of radio, television, and now the internet, fans have found new ways of following and supporting their favorite players, teams, television shows, etc. However, social media have not only provided an opportunity to connect with fellow fans, it has also provided a way to personally connect to the object of fan-obsession. So this begs the question: has this new form of interaction pushed fan boundaries too far?

With the emergence of Facebook, Twitter, Youtube, and other such social networking sites, it has become easier to stay up-to-date with star athletes, celebrities, and the like. Almost instantly, you can watch a replay of a football play or be informed of the stats of every major baseball game happening at the same time. People now have the ability to live-tweet about reality shows, singing competitions, and other such events. And now the investment is reciprocated. Athletes can now get feedback from their fans about their opinions and thoughts on games and overall efficiency of the team. They can personally answer a fan about a question or thank someone for their support. In addition to that, Twitter is also a promotional tool for games or tournaments. This new way of interacting is a much better and easier outlet to show devotion to a certain fandom. In general, this seems like a great way for fans to be supportive of their favorite teams and athletes and to connect to them on a more personal level. Examples of certain athletes and coaches using Twitter can be found here:

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2009/writers/the_bonus/06/05/twitter.sports/index.html

BUT. The same can be said of displaying hatred for a rival team. Cyber-bullying is no new thing, and now with Twitter and Facebook fan pages, people can directly attack someone whom they dislike. And man, can some individuals be vicious! I personally don’t understand the need to rip someone apart via the internet (or in person, for that matter), so I have a hard time comprehending how people can be so completely rude and spiteful to someone they don’t even know. There is honestly no need to wish someone dead just because they play for a rival team or made a mistake in their PRIVATE life, which is part of being human. Because people can now personally connect to the object of their rage, barriers are being broken between public figures and private citizens.

One example of hate tweeting is a follower of the 49ers football player Brandon Jacobs. After being injured during a game, the Twitter follower said, “I hope you die a horrible death.” Jacobs handled the situation in a graceful manner, which can be read here:

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap1000000055813/article/brandon-jacobs-responds-to-twitter-hate-messages

 

This and other such instances bring up the issue of whether or not Twitter and Facebook have allowed fans and other users to have too much access to celebrities and athletes. Should these social networking sites be monitored for hate messages? If there were a way to monitor and limit these kinds of online attacks, who should have that kind of control?

Advertisements

One thought on “Twitter: Helpful or Harmful?

  1. Fans have always been crazy. They don’t need social media to help them go too far. Bryan Stow, the San Francisco Giants fan who was beaten in the parking lot of a Dodgers game by two Dodgers fans, is good example of fans going too far without social media. The Alabama fan that poisoned a landmark tree at Auburn and then went on the radio to brag about it is another example. Those are just two more recent examples.

    If anything I feel that twitter might help fans vent their anger in a more non-violent way, even though what some fans say can be offensive. (Why do fans get angry over a sport in the first place? I don’t know.) Fans can direct their displeasure at players or coaches via the internet instead of at other fans. Yes that displeasure, and sometimes hate, can cross the line. I don’t feel that twitter is that harmful because people would be hateful even without twitter, it is just the way of the world (unfortunately). It makes the hate more public ad gives people the opportunity to point out the wrongs in peoples speech and actions.

    Monitoring social networking sites for hate messages sounds like a good idea but seems very unfeasible. Even if the social messaging sites were monitored, banning someone from a site won’t stop that person because there are so many outlets on the internet for them to speak.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s