Regulation of the Internet and Social Media

Over the past few years, the debate over internet regulation has become more heated. There are many different ways to approach regulating the internet but enforcing the regulations is the part that would be difficult, if even possible. Most people agree that there does need to be some form of regulation for the internet, but how can something that is used all the time, all around the world, and used by billions of people be regulated?

There are two main competing views on how to approach this problem. One approach is that the government should establish laws to regulate certain content on the internet. This approach runs into stiff criticism from people due to limitations on free speech. Who would determine whether something would be allowed to be posted online? I find the government to be a vague and unsatisfactory answer. Another problem that arises with government regulation of the internet and social media is that the government works to slowly, especially if it would be dealing with something as fast and ever changing as the internet. The government is not adaptable enough to keep up with the speed in which new technology arrive and the way in which people use it. Another problem that comes up with government regulation is that the internet is a worldwide product. Would each country come up with their own set of regulations? Some countries already heavily regulate the internet content inside their borders, such as North Korea and China. Once you start down the path of government regulation, where would would it stop? Where would the line be for acceptable material and not acceptable material?

The other popular approach to regulation is self regulation. This means that the social media sites and the like monitor and regulate themselves before the government decides to do it for them. It would be easier for administrators of sites to regulate themselves than having people from the government regulate all the sites. Of course the problem of where the line would be still would exist, but it would be up to the people who created and operate the site to determine the content they will allow instead of having someone else decide for them. Only the government is prohibited from blocking speech, not the administrators of particular sites.

There is always the option of what John Palfrey calls the open internet. This is very few restrictions and regulations, if any at all. It is almost like an anything goes attitude. This is a risky approach because all kinds of violent, graphic, and sexual content would be available to anyone, including children who should not be allowed to view it.

I tend to think self regulation is the best approach but in reality there is no perfect way to solve this problem. Some people will be upset no matter what approach is taken. Enforcing the regulations is a problem as well. Would there be a punishment for posting material deemed unfit for viewing? Self regulation sounds like a nice theory but in practice would it really work?

Advertisements

One thought on “Regulation of the Internet and Social Media

  1. I agree that this is a very difficult situation in which one solution will not please everyone. Any form of regulation of the Internet will make someone unhappy, and an open Internet will also upset some people. I also feel that self-regulation is the best option, even though everyone would not agree. It is not the government’s place to regulate the Internet, who knows how far they would take that regulation. It is also not wise to have an open Internet as there is a lot of material that should not be on a public domain.

    http://www.forbes.com/sites/scottcleland/2011/11/07/the-politics-of-regulating-the-internet/

    This article shows just how difficult it is to determine who should regulate the Internet, if anyone. Clearly these issues have been around since the Internet was created, but it seems that the pace of technological advancement calls for a solution sooner rather than later. With the popularity of social networks like Twitter and Facebook, regulating the Internet has become an important issue. I feel that self regulation is the wisest choice for now, because those who created social networks should be the authority of those networks. They have the right to regulate what is said or posted on their sites. The matter of regulating the Internet is a difficult one with no clear solution; hopefully our country can find an answer that maintains our liberties and freedom of speech.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s